My.ADVISOR.com Sign-In
ID
Password

Member Center / Sign-Up
Go to Article
Advanced Search 

LITIGATION MANAGEMENT

Plan Your E-Discovery Strategy

Early planning for e-discovery is crucial to a successful litigation strategy.

By Valerie Fogel Inforzato, Esq., Pacific Legal consultant, and Jason Derting, Pacific Legal CEO

Because businesses store so much information electronically, lawyers and courts are increasingly more detailed in their demands for electronic documents and data. This article gives you practical tips and considerations about electronic data discovery (EDD), including preservation, discovering computing environment information, court rules and case law authority concerning EDD requests, discovery limitations, cost allocation, and EDD procedural court orders.

Preserving electronic documents and data

Sending a preservation letter when a lawsuit is imminent or has been served is critical to minimizing loss of documents and data. You should send a preservation letter to not only the opposing party or counsel, but also your client (or if you're in-house counsel, to your company’s staff).

Tips for preservation letters:

  • Determine if your situation meets the criteria for a temporary restraining order, and if so, request one.
  • Be specific. For example, list names of pertinent individuals, document formats such as e-mails, e-mail attachments, and native file formats. Specify document categories such as letters, reports, ledgers, and invoices, and time periods. Being specific can enhance your ability to prove knowledge and intent of spoliation.
  • Request preservation of electronic devices, storage media at the user and network levels, software, and manuals. List all known locations, such as the workplace, homes, personal/portable devices, remote offices, etc.
  • Request cessation of any deletion of present and future active, archive, and back-up tapes/media, until an exact "mirror" data image of the storage is made. If a complete image is not possible, request a complete back-up or other copy of all the data. However, a mirror image will include deleted and residual data, while a data back-up will not.
  • Request stoppage of any de-fragmentation to preserve deleted data. Request that all relevant data from drives, disks, cartridges, tapes, memory cards and other media be backed up immediately.
  • Send a letter of preservation, even if intentional spoliation is unlikely. Equipment, storage media and data may be discarded or deleted routinely and innocently.
  • Follow up the preservation letter with a motion and agreed or court-directed preservation order.

Advisor Tip
To preserve off-network documents and data such as files and e-mail messages, you might request that they be stored on the network prior to making a mirror image.

Requesting Native File Formats
Common reasons for demanding electronic documents and data (in native file format) are:
  • To gain access to metadata, which is generally not included within a printed version of a document (i.e. data about the data, e.g. authors, recipients, dates/times of creation/ modifications/last access, openings and blind carbon copies)
  • To reveal more accurately the documents in their dynamic data structure (Access, Excel, Works etc.), rather than in a static paper replication
  • To search and access documents electronically; and to reproduce documents and data onto CDs or other transferable storage media. Electronic discovery procedures can vary depending on the case and the dynamic innovations and changes of electronic discovery software processes.

Advisor Tip
When presenting electronic data and metadata in court, consider using a projected full-screen shot of the particular computer file as an "original output," shown to "reflect the data accurately," pursuant to Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 1001(3). You can also present a printed or projected image (e.g., TIFF or PDF) of a computer-generated document as an original output or printout, pursuant to Rule 1001(3).

Plan Your E-Discovery Strategy

No reader comments ... yet.

    What do YOU think about this topic? Share your advice and thoughts using this form.

    Your Name

    REQUIRED : PUBLIC

    Your E-Mail

    REQUIRED : PRIVATE

    Job, Company

    OPTIONAL : PUBLIC

    City, State, Country

    OPTIONAL : PUBLIC

    Your Web Site

    OPTIONAL : PUBLIC

    Your Comment

    Please help everyone by keeping your comments on-topic, using clean language, and not defaming or making personal attacks.


    Your e-mail address is required, but it will not be displayed to the public or given to anyone. See our Privacy Policy. Comments become visible after they pass our spam filter, and spammers and abusers are permanently blocked. Please report spam or abuse.

    Valerie Fogel Inforzato, Esq.Valerie Fogel Inforzato has been a lawyer for 20 years. She is a consultant for Pacific Legal Litigation Support Services of Portland, Oregon, supervising EDD production projects. Valerie’s legal experience includes civil and criminal litigation cases in New York, Oklahoma, Oregon, and Washington. Valerie is also an assistant staff judge advocate with the U.S. Army Reserves JAG Branch.

    Jason DertingJason Derting is the CEO of Pacific Legal Litigation Support Services and has been in the litigation support industry for more than ten years. Jason has developed more than 100 software programs, written articles, and lectured throughout the country.

    Printer-friendly
    page layout

    Keyword Tags: Case Law, Computer System, Database, E-Discovery, E-Mail, Law, Law Technology, Lawyer Tech, Native file format, Preservation, Storage, Web Browsing

    ARTICLE INFO

    DataBased Advisor

    Print Edition: Premiere 2005, Page 8

    FREE ACCESS FREE ACCESS

    SUBSCRIPTION STATUS
    You are not signed-in. If you are a subscriber to this publication, sign-in above to access locked articles. To subscribe or renew go to www.AdvisorStore.com.

    Subscribe to DATABASED.ADVISOR.com

    Get it all -- every current and past ADVISOR tech/business publication, now all-in-one subscription, with new articles and a huge reference library packed with expert advice, how-to and downloads. Subscribe now to get it all.

    DataBased.Advisor.com

    Subscribe to FileMaker Advisor Magazine

    Read the advanced guide to creating custom business database solutions with FileMaker software. Subscribe now to gain access to all the archives and downloads.

    FileMaker.Advisor.com

    Subscribe to Advisor Basics of FileMaker Pro

    Learn the fundamentals of using FileMaker Pro software. Every issue gives you step-by-step instructions on creating the databases you need. Subscribe now!

    FileMaker.AdvisorBasics.com

    Showcase Your Smarts

    Submit your tips, techniques and advice and let Advisor promote your business and build your career. Show the world what you know!

    AdvisorTips.com

    Use of this or any other site, content, product or service of Advisor Media constitutes acceptance of Terms of Use.
    Portions copyright ©1983-2008 Advisor Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    Reuse or reproduction of any portion or quantity of Advisor Media's copyrighted content, in any form, for any purpose, requires written permission.
    ADVISOR®, the ADVISOR logo, and other names and logos that incorporate ADVISOR are registered trademarks, trademarks or service marks of Advisor Media, Inc. in the United States and/or other countries.
    Other trademarks are used for identification, editorial or descriptive purposes and are the property of their owners.
    Hosted by Prominic.NET Website powered by
    LOTUS SOFTWARE
    INFOV01 posted 07/28/2005 modified 01/07/2009 03:37:21 AM ztdbms/ztdbms
    domino-144.advisor.com my.advisor.com 01/07/2009 02:33:15 PM